Tesco equal pay: Why the job manuals matter

Facts of the case

Tesco store workers began bringing equal pay claims in 2018. They argued that their work was of equal value to work in Tesco’s distribution centres. In 2023, the employment tribunal spent 36 days establishing what the jobs involved so that independent experts could compare the demands of the roles.

AI-generated workplace illustration. Tesco equal pay: Why the job manuals matter
AI-generated illustration.

The parties had prepared detailed descriptions of the sample jobs for the litigation. One store worker’s description alone generated 1,427 points of dispute. One Tesco manager’s witness statement about a single comparison job ran to 187 pages. The tribunal was concerned that this approach focused heavily on what particular people happened to do, without making enough use of the instructions Tesco gave its staff at the time.

Issues and how they were decided

The first issue was what counts as part of a job. A task may demand skill, effort or judgement even if it comes up only occasionally. The tribunal used Tesco’s detailed training materials to establish what workers could be expected to do, while allowing evidence from the workplace to show where the instructions and practice differed.

Tesco challenged the tribunal’s approach. On 12 May 2026 the Court of Appeal held that the tribunal could rely on the materials in these circumstances. A manual might leave out things workers do routinely or list duties that never arise in practice. The tribunal had taken account of that possibility.

Tesco did succeed on a separate ground. The tribunal had made some findings contrary to facts the parties had agreed. The Court of Appeal held that the tribunal should have respected those agreements. The Supreme Court refused permission to appeal on 29 September 2026. The May judgment dealt with the evidence and the way the case should proceed. It made no final ruling on equal value or back pay.

Tesco wanted the tribunal to hear that stage of the case again. The Court of Appeal rejected Tesco’s main objections to the use of the manuals. A standard instruction may establish what someone is expected to do on the rare occasion a problem arises. The court accepted that evidence from the workplace could displace an instruction that did not reflect the real job. The result was a ruling about what the experts can rely on when comparing the jobs.

Lessons for trade union representatives

Start with the written instructions and ask workers where they match the job. Who sorts out a problem when a delivery is wrong? Who has to decide whether equipment is safe to use? What changes on a short-staffed shift? Keep dates and examples. If a written instruction has stopped being used, record that too. A comparison is stronger when both sides can see what the documents capture and what they miss.

When you ask members for examples, record the instruction in force at the time, who carried it out and how much judgement it required. Keep a record of the points both sides agree. In a large claim, that can prevent hours of evidence being spent on a fact nobody disputes.

Supreme Court case history Permission to appeal decision.

Full judgment
Tesco Stores Ltd v Ms K Element and others [2026] EWCA Civ 580

By Pat Harrington

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.